Equal pay: More on the Asda equal pay claims

Employment / 07 September 2017


In Asda Stores Ltd v Mrs S Brierley and ors the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) has confirmed that a group of women who work in Asda’s retail stores can compare themselves with higher paid men who work in distribution centres for the purposes of an important equal pay claim.

You can read our last briefing on the Asda case here.

Asda appealed to the EAT, arguing that comparison between the two groups of workers was not possible because the retail stores and distribution centres were managed by different bodies and there were different methods of setting pay in each workplace.

The EAT rejected this argument and found that where there is a “single source” (i.e. a body responsible for the inequality which could restore the equal treatment) in control of pay arrangements and conditions for both groups of workers, a direct comparison is permitted.

On this basis, the EAT decided that the tribunal had been correct in their ruling last year; the roles were judged to be of equal value and could be compared.

However, the EAT has given Asda permission to appeal to the Court of Appeal and so we will need to “watch this space” for further developments.


The judgment was issued on 31 August 2017.


The decision allows more than 7,000 workers to proceed with their claims and may open the floodgates for other supermarket equal pay claims.


We will continue to update you on key developments as the Asda case progresses. In the meantime, employers should review their pay structures and whether there are positions which are paid differently but are equal in delivery value.


Sign up call to action button

This update is for general purposes and guidance only and does not constitute legal or professional advice. You should seek legal advice before relying on its content. This update relates to the prevailing circumstances at the date of its original publication and may not have been updated to reflect subsequent developments. If you have general queries about our updates, please email: mailinglists@greenwoodsgrm.co.uk

Get in touch with us

Interested in finding out more? Use this form to let us know how to contact you and what you’d like to know, and we’ll get back to you.

Alternatively, contact anyone listed on our website direct, they will be happy to hear from you.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.